foodindex.co

PC-SPESBanned Substance

For informational use only; not medical advice. Check with your doctor before starting, particularly if taking other meds.

PC-SPES was an eight-herb capsule sold by BotanicLab from 1996, marketed for prostate health and studied as a complementary therapy in prostate cancer [1][3].

The blend: Baikal skullcap, chrysanthemum, reishi mushroom, isatis (dyer's woad), licorice, ginseng or pseudoginseng, Rabdosia rubescens and saw palmetto [1].

That was the label. Testing across the product's manufacturing history found three prescription drugs that appeared on no label at all [4].

It was recalled nationwide in February 2002 and is not legally available in the United States today [2][4].

Why It's Banned

  • The adulterants are the whole story here. In February 2002 the California Department of Health Services found warfarin — a prescription blood thinner — in PC-SPES capsules [1][2][4].

    BotanicLab voluntarily recalled the product nationwide the same month [2][4]. [4]

  • Warfarin was not the first finding. In August 2001 an independent lab, Rocky Mountain Instrumental Laboratory, found the synthetic estrogen diethylstilbestrol (DES) in 3 of 6 tested lots from two sources [4].

    A third drug, the anti-inflammatory indomethacin, was measured in lots made between 1996 and mid-1999 [4]. [4]

  • The companion product SPES, marketed for immune support, was separately found to contain the prescription anti-anxiety drug alprazolam (Xanax) [1][2]. [1]

  • Why these particular drugs mattered so much: men were taking PC-SPES for its estrogen-like effect on PSA and testosterone [4].

    The hidden DES delivered exactly that — an unlicensed hormone drug at an unpredictable dose [4]. The hidden warfarin added uncontrolled bleeding risk on top [4]. [4]

  • One disagreement in the record was never resolved. BotanicLab's own submitted sample tested negative for DES in August 2001 [4].

    The independent lab, testing separately-sourced lots from the same period, found DES in half of them [4][9]. [4]

  • The broader point is not specific to this one product. A botanical blend's ingredient list describes what the maker says went in, not what an analytical lab finds in the capsule [4].

    PC-SPES is the case where that gap was measured drug by drug, across years of production [4]. [4]

Health Hazards

  • The two causes could never be separated. PC-SPES's adverse effects came from the herbs' own estrogen-like activity, the hidden prescription adulterants, or both [3][4].

    Sources flag this explicitly as unresolved, not as a settled attribution [3][4]. [4]

  • Because the dominant effect mimicked estrogen therapy, the common side effects mirrored it [4].

    Nipple tenderness was reported in 34.8% to 100% of patients across studies, and gynecomastia (breast enlargement) in 8% to 8.7% [4]. [4]

  • Gastrointestinal and circulatory effects were common too [4].

    Diarrhea in 13% to 38.6% of patients, dyspepsia or nausea in 15.7% to 21.7%, and leg cramps or swelling in 2% to 68.5% [4]. [4]

  • Blood clots are the serious signal. Thromboembolic events were reported in 5% to 6.2% of patients across studies [4].

    Case reports document pulmonary embolism, deep vein thrombosis, disseminated intravascular coagulation and abdominal-cavity hemorrhage [1][3][4]. [4]

  • A 1998 study in the New England Journal of Medicine is stark on this [5].

    All 8 of 8 prostate cancer patients taking PC-SPES had breast tenderness and loss of libido, and one developed a superficial venous thrombosis [5]. [5]

  • Two published case reports go further [3].

    One describes an acquired bleeding disorder (coagulopathy) in a patient taking PC-SPES, discussed as possibly contamination-related [3]. A separate one describes disseminated intravascular coagulation associated with its use [3]. [3]

Regulatory Timeline

  • 1996 — PC-SPES goes on sale in the US, over the counter, with no prescription needed [3]. [3]

  • 1997 — the herbal formula is patented in the United States [4]. [4]

  • 2001 — allegations of DES contamination begin circulating among prostate cancer patients online [4]. [4]

  • August 2001 — an independent lab tests 6 lots from 2 sources and finds DES in 3 of them [4].

    BotanicLab's own submitted sample from the same period tests negative [4]. [4]

  • February 28, 2002 — California's health department finds warfarin in PC-SPES and alprazolam in SPES [1][2][4].

    BotanicLab voluntarily recalls both products nationwide [1][2][4]. [4]

  • March 2002 — the FDA issues an additional public warning after the manufacturer's recall [8]. [8]

  • May 1, 2002 — the FDA's Enforcement Report classifies the recall Class I, its most serious category: a reasonable probability of serious adverse health consequences or death [8]. [8]

  • June 2002 — BotanicLab shuts down its operations entirely [9].

    A class action lawsuit is filed alleging it sold mislabeled dietary supplements [9]. [9]

  • Today — PC-SPES is not legally available in the United States, because the only company licensed by the patent holder to make it is no longer in business [4][6][7]. [4]

Dangerous Amount

No source reviewed establishes a human lethal dose or a toxic threshold specific to PC-SPES [4].

What is documented is contamination levels. Indomethacin measured 1.07 to 13.19 mg/g in lots made from 1996 through mid-1999, and DES 107.28 to 159.27 µg/g in the same lots [4].

Those early lots were 2 to 6 times more antineoplastic and up to 50 times more estrogenic in laboratory testing than lots made after spring 1999, tracking their higher drug content [4].

Serious harm followed ordinary daily use rather than a single overdose. One documented retroperitoneal hemorrhage occurred in a 62-year-old man after about one month of unsupervised use [1]. [4]

Accidental Exposure

There is no PC-SPES-specific poison-control protocol, and no established safe or dangerous exposure threshold for accidental ingestion [7][10].

NCI's patient guidance is general: tell every healthcare provider about any dietary supplement, herb, vitamin, mineral or home remedy being taken [7].

In the published bleeding-disorder and DIC case reports, management centred on identifying PC-SPES as the cause, stopping it, and correcting the coagulation abnormality [3].

US Poison Control (National Capital Poison Center) offers free, confidential triage at 1-800-222-1222 or triage.webpoisoncontrol.org [10]. Call 911 immediately if the person collapses, has a seizure, has trouble breathing, or cannot be woken [10]. [10]

Common Questions

Is PC-SPES still sold anywhere?

The original patented formula is not legally sold in the US [4][6][7].

BotanicLab, the only licensed manufacturer, closed after the 2002 recall, and the FDA never approved the product as a cancer therapy [4][6].

Sources disagree on what that means in practice. A 2023 clinical review from CAM Cancer/NAFKAM states it remains accessible through internet order from unofficial sources [3].

None of the sources reviewed addressed the legality of personally possessing or importing old stock [4][6][7].

What brand names was PC-SPES sold under?

The original was sold as PC SPES by BotanicLab of Brea, California [1].

A related product for prostate symptoms, under a different formulation, was sold as Prostate-Res by ARC Nutrition [1].

Did PC-SPES do anything for prostate cancer?

It had a real biological effect, which is part of why the story matters [5].

A 1998 New England Journal of Medicine study documented estrogen-like activity lowering PSA and testosterone in prostate cancer patients [5].

Here is the unresolved problem. The hidden DES found in the capsules is a synthetic estrogen that would produce that same effect [4].

The FDA never approved PC-SPES as a cancer therapy, and the herbs' own contribution was never separated from the adulterants' [3][4].

Are the replacement products any safer?

PC-HOPE, PC-CARE and PC-PLUS were marketed as replacements, using a similar herb blend made under different quality control [3][6].

They are not the patented original formula [6].

Only limited preliminary studies exist for them, and none establish an effect on prostate cancer [3][6].

Sources

  1. PC-SPES | Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center — mskcc.org. https://www.mskcc.org/cancer-care/integrative-medicine/herbs/pc-spes (date unknown)
  2. Integrative Medicine: FDA Issues Recall of PC SPES & SPES | Memorial Sloan Kettering Cancer Center — mskcc.org. https://www.mskcc.org/cancer-care/diagnosis-treatment/symptom-management/integrative-medicine/herbs/news-alerts/fda-issues-recall-pc-spes-spes (date unknown)
  3. NAFKAM — PC-SPES — nafkam.no. https://nafkam.no/en/pc-spes (date unknown)
  4. PC-SPES - Complementary and Alternative Medicine (PDQ®) — cancer.gov. https://www.cancer.gov/about-cancer/treatment/cam/hp/pc-spes-pdq (date unknown)
  5. The New England Journal of Medicine — Clinical and Biologic Activity of an Estrogenic Herbal Combination (PC-SPES) in Prostate Cancer | NEJM — nejm.org. https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJM199809173391201 (date unknown)
  6. PC-SPES, PC-HOPE, PC-CARE and PC-PLUS — cancerresearchuk.org. https://www.cancerresearchuk.org/about-cancer/treatment/complementary-alternative-therapies/individual-therapies/pc-spes-pc-hope (date unknown)
  7. PC-SPES (PDQ®): Integrative, alternative, and complementary therapies - Patient Information [NCI] – Health Information Library | PeaceHealth — peacehealth.org. https://www.peacehealth.org/medical-topics/id/ncicdr0000467217 (date unknown)
  8. More Information on Recall of PC-SPES - Prostate Supplement - May 3, 2002 - ConsumerLab.com — consumerlab.com. https://www.consumerlab.com/recalls/10012/more-information-on-recall-of-pc-spes-prostate-supplement/ (date unknown)
  9. Tom et al., JNCI: Journal of the National Cancer Institute — academic.oup.com. https://academic.oup.com/jnci/article-abstract/94/17/1266/2519883 (2002-09-03)
  10. Poison Control | Your trusted resource — poison.org. https://www.poison.org/ (date unknown)
Spot a mistake or have an idea? .

Tell us

What’s this about?

Menu

Search